Back to Plantar Fasciitis Advice

Orthotix Advice Centre

Off-The-Shelf vs Custom Orthotics

Off-the-shelf and custom orthotics can both provide effective foot support when appropriately selected. Off-the-shelf orthotics are manufactured in standard sizes and support profiles, while custom orthotics are individually prescribed and manufactured following an assessment of the person’s feet, symptoms and functional requirements.

A custom device is not automatically necessary for every case of plantar fasciitis or arch discomfort. Many people can begin with a well-fitting prefabricated orthotic, while custom manufacture may be more appropriate where the feet require different support, a deformity needs accommodating or standard devices have repeatedly been unsuccessful.
Off-The-Shelf vs Custom Orthotics

Quick Answer

Orthotic insoles can help some people with symptomatic overpronation by supporting the arch, improving rearfoot stability and reducing excessive or poorly controlled inward movement while the device is worn. They are most appropriate when pronation is associated with pain, fatigue or difficulty with activity—not simply because the feet look flat.

What Is Pronation?

Pronation is the natural inward movement of the foot as it accepts weight during walking or running.

This movement helps the foot:

  • Adapt to the ground
  • Absorb impact
  • Distribute pressure
  • Maintain balance
  • Move smoothly from heel contact towards push-off

Pronation is not automatically a problem. Everyone’s feet move differently, and some inward movement is expected during normal walking.

Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS guidance describes pronation as the natural side-to-side movement of the feet during walking and running.

What Does Overpronation Mean?

The term overpronation is commonly used when the foot appears to roll inward more than expected or remains in a pronated position for longer during movement.

It may be associated with:

  • A lowered arch during weight-bearing
  • The heel appearing to tilt inward
  • The ankle moving towards the inside
  • Shoes wearing more heavily along the inner edge
  • The foot appearing wider or flatter when standing
  • Reduced stability during walking or running

However, there is no single visual measurement that determines whether pronation is harmful.

A person may have visibly pronated or flat feet without experiencing pain, weakness or limitation. Another person may have a relatively ordinary-looking arch but still experience symptoms related to footwear, activity or pressure distribution.

The presence of symptoms and functional difficulty is therefore more important than appearance alone.

Is Overpronation A Medical Condition?

Not necessarily.

Overpronation is usually a description of foot movement rather than a diagnosis by itself.

It becomes more clinically relevant when it appears to contribute to:

  • Plantar heel pain
  • Arch discomfort
  • Foot fatigue
  • Ankle instability
  • Repeated lower-limb symptoms
  • Reduced walking tolerance
  • Difficulty completing work or exercise
  • Rapid or uneven footwear wear

Flat or pronated feet that are painless and function normally generally do not require treatment. The NHS states that flat feet usually cause no problems and should not prevent normal activity or sport.

How May Orthotic Insoles Help?

A structured orthotic may alter how the foot is supported inside the shoe.

Depending on its shape and construction, it may:

  • Increase contact beneath the arch
  • Support the medial side of the foot
  • Stabilise the heel
  • Redistribute pressure
  • Resist excessive compression
  • Reduce the amount or speed of inward rearfoot movement
  • Improve comfort during prolonged activity
  • Make supportive footwear feel more stable

Orthotic insoles generally work by supporting or cushioning the foot or changing how the wearer stands and walks. Their effects are present mainly while the device is being worn.

They do not permanently rebuild an arch or permanently remove pronation.

Do Orthotics Completely Stop Pronation?

No—and completely stopping pronation would not normally be the objective.

Pronation is part of normal movement. An orthotic may instead aim to:

  • Reduce excessive movement
  • Slow the rate of inward movement
  • Improve rearfoot stability
  • Redistribute pressure
  • Make activity more comfortable
  • Reduce strain through a symptomatic area

Research suggests that orthotic design features such as medial posting can reduce peak rearfoot eversion, but the measured changes are generally modest and evidence varies considerably between studies.

The success of an orthotic should therefore be judged by improvements in comfort, stability and function rather than whether the foot appears perfectly straight.

What Does The Research Say?

The evidence for using orthoses specifically for adult flatfoot or overpronation remains mixed.

Reviews have reported possible improvements in:

  • Pain
  • Physical function
  • Standing stability
  • Walking efficiency
  • Rearfoot movement
  • Pressure and loading patterns

However, the studies use different orthotics, patient groups and outcome measurements, which makes firm conclusions difficult.

A systematic review of orthoses for adults with flat feet concluded that the available evidence was limited and that better-quality randomised trials were needed.

Another review found some evidence that orthoses may improve function and alter loading or rearfoot movement, but it did not identify high-level evidence supporting orthoses for every person with flexible flat feet.

This supports a cautious approach: orthotics may help selected symptomatic users, but they should not be marketed as universally correcting overpronation.

Who May Benefit From Orthotic Support?

An orthotic insole may be worth considering where pronation is accompanied by:

  • Pain beneath the arch
  • Plantar heel pain
  • Tired or aching feet
  • Poor rearfoot stability
  • Difficulty standing for prolonged periods
  • Recurring discomfort during walking
  • Excessive shoe wear
  • Repeated ankle symptoms
  • A recommendation from a qualified professional

A structured device may be particularly useful where a flat cushioning insole does not provide enough support.

An orthotic is less likely to be necessary where:

  • The feet are comfortable
  • Walking and balance are unaffected
  • No repeated injuries occur
  • Activities can be completed normally
  • The only concern is how the arches look

Treatment should address a problem rather than an appearance.

Can Orthotics Help Symptomatic Flat Feet?

They may help relieve pain, stiffness or fatigue associated with symptomatic flat feet.

A contoured orthotic can provide:

  • Contact beneath the lowered arch
  • Greater rearfoot stability
  • Pressure redistribution
  • A supportive surface inside footwear
  • Reduced fatigue during prolonged standing
  • Improved comfort during walking

The NHS lists shoe insoles, supportive footwear and stretches among the options that may help when flat feet cause symptoms. These measures may reduce pain or stiffness but do not permanently change foot shape.

A newly developed or one-sided flat foot requires assessment because it may have a different cause from a long-standing flexible foot shape.

Can Orthotics Help Plantar Fasciitis Associated With Pronation?

Potentially.

Where plantar heel pain occurs alongside a need for greater arch or rearfoot support, a structured orthotic may:

  • Support the medial arch
  • Cushion the heel
  • Redistribute pressure
  • Improve stability
  • Make weight-bearing more comfortable

However, plantar fasciitis is not caused by overpronation in every person.

Other relevant factors may include:

  • Increased walking or running
  • Prolonged standing
  • Hard flooring
  • Calf or ankle tightness
  • Unsuitable footwear
  • Reduced strength or load tolerance
  • Recovery between demanding activities

Orthotic support should therefore form part of a broader plan that may include footwear, stretching, strengthening and appropriate activity management.

Can Orthotics Help Arch Fatigue?

Yes, where unsupported or poorly controlled foot movement contributes to fatigue.

A contoured insole may increase the area of contact beneath the arch and distribute pressure more broadly.

This may help people who experience:

  • Aching through the arch after work
  • Tired feet during long walks
  • Discomfort when standing on hard floors
  • A feeling that the feet collapse inward
  • Reduced tolerance for unsupportive footwear

The arch contour should feel supportive rather than sharply prominent.

Dorset HealthCare describes medial arch supports as devices that support the midfoot and relieve stresses.

Can Orthotics Help Ankle Stability?

They may improve the sense of stability for some people by supporting the heel and midfoot inside the shoe.

Possible features include:

  • A shaped heel cup
  • Firmer rearfoot material
  • Medial arch support
  • Rearfoot posting
  • Wedges
  • A broad and stable base

However, repeated ankle injuries, weakness or significant balance difficulty should be assessed rather than managed through an over-the-counter insole alone.

Rehabilitation may also involve:

  • Calf strengthening
  • Balance exercises
  • Ankle-control exercises
  • Foot-muscle work
  • Suitable footwear
  • Gradual return to demanding activity

An orthotic may support rehabilitation but does not replace muscular strength and coordination.

What Features May Help Control Excessive Pronation?

Orthotic designs intended to provide greater control may include:

A Contoured Medial Arch

This increases contact beneath the inside of the foot and may help support the midfoot.

A Shaped Heel Cup

A heel cup helps contain the rearfoot and may reduce side-to-side movement inside the shoe.

Rearfoot Posting

A firmer or angled section beneath the heel may influence rearfoot position and loading.

Medial Wedging

A wedge beneath the inner side of the device may be used to alter pressure and movement.

Firm, Resilient Materials

Materials that resist compression may provide more consistent support than very soft foam.

Full-Length Construction

A full-length orthotic provides a continuous surface beneath the foot and can include cushioning beneath the heel and forefoot.

No single feature is correct for every foot. Excessive control or an overly prominent arch can create discomfort.

Is A Higher Arch Support Better?

No.

An arch support that is too high may create concentrated pressure beneath the middle of the foot.

This can cause:

  • Sharp arch pain
  • Burning or aching
  • Numbness
  • Instability
  • The feeling of being pushed towards the outside of the shoe
  • Reduced tolerance for walking
  • New forefoot or heel pressure

The contour should broadly match the wearer’s arch rather than force the foot into a predetermined shape.

More correction is not automatically more effective.

Are Firmer Orthotics Better For Overpronation?

A firmer device may resist compression and provide more consistent support, but it is not automatically the best option.

A Firmer Orthotic May Be Appropriate When

  • Greater rearfoot support is required
  • A softer device collapses too easily
  • The wearer is highly active
  • More durable structural support is needed
  • Professional modification is planned

A Softer Orthotic May Be Appropriate When

  • The feet are pressure-sensitive
  • Strong support has previously been uncomfortable
  • Cushioning is also a priority
  • The wearer is adapting to an orthotic
  • Greater accommodation is required

The correct density depends on symptoms, foot shape, activity, body weight, footwear and personal tolerance.

Full-Length vs Three-Quarter-Length Orthotics

Both formats can provide arch and rearfoot support.

Full-Length Orthotics

These extend beneath the entire foot and may provide:

  • Arch support
  • Rearfoot stability
  • Heel cushioning
  • Forefoot cushioning
  • Pressure distribution from heel to toe
  • A continuous internal shoe surface

They usually require deeper footwear or removal of the original shoe liner.

Three-Quarter-Length Orthotics

These finish behind the ball of the foot and may fit more easily inside:

  • Formal shoes
  • Shallower footwear
  • Shoes without removable liners
  • Footwear with limited toe-box depth

They provide less direct forefoot cushioning but may be easier to accommodate.

The Bio Advanced range is available in full-length and three-quarter-length constructions, although the available sizes and densities should be checked when ordering.

Off-The-Shelf vs Custom Orthotics

Both types may be used for symptomatic pronation.

Off-The-Shelf Orthotics

These are manufactured in standard:

  • Sizes
  • Arch profiles
  • Densities
  • Shapes
  • Support levels

They may be suitable where:

  • Foot shape is relatively straightforward
  • Both feet need similar support
  • Symptoms are uncomplicated
  • The chosen contour fits comfortably
  • Extensive modification is unnecessary

Some prefabricated devices can still be heat moulded, ground or professionally adjusted.

Custom Orthotics

These are manufactured following an individual assessment and prescription.

They may be considered where:

  • Each foot needs different support
  • Foot shape is unusual
  • A deformity requires accommodation
  • A specific area requires targeted pressure relief
  • Standard devices repeatedly fail
  • Previous surgery or injury has changed the foot
  • A more complex prescription is required

Evidence does not support the assumption that everyone with pronated feet needs a custom device. The appropriate option is the one that provides suitable, comfortable support for the individual requirement.

Dedicated guide:

Off-The-Shelf vs Custom Orthotics

Should Orthotics Be Worn In Both Shoes?

Orthotic insoles are normally worn as a pair.

This helps provide:

  • Similar height on both sides
  • Balanced support
  • Consistent footwear fit
  • A more even walking experience
  • Reduced risk of creating an unintended leg-length difference

The two orthotics may still contain different modifications where professionally prescribed.

Do not independently add extra wedges, lifts or pads to only one side unless there is a clear clinical reason.

What Footwear Works Best?

Orthotics work together with the footwear.

Suitable shoes should ideally provide:

  • Adequate internal depth
  • Sufficient width
  • Enough toe room
  • A secure lace, strap or hook-and-loop fastening
  • A firm heel counter
  • A stable sole
  • A removable original liner
  • A heel that remains securely contained

NHS orthotic guidance advises choosing footwear that accommodates the orthotic comfortably, often with a removable liner, secure fastening and a broad, stable sole.

An orthotic cannot fully compensate for footwear that is:

  • Too shallow
  • Too narrow
  • Too short
  • Badly worn
  • Unstable
  • Poorly fastened
  • Unsuitable for the activity

Are Stability Shoes Enough Without Orthotics?

They may be for some people.

Supportive or stability footwear may provide:

  • A firmer heel counter
  • A broader base
  • A more stable midsole
  • Greater resistance to inward movement
  • Better cushioning
  • Improved fit around the foot

Someone with mild symptoms may find suitable footwear sufficient without an additional orthotic.

Others may benefit from combining supportive footwear with an appropriately fitted insole.

The combination should not feel excessively rigid or crowded.

Should The Existing Shoe Liner Be Removed?

Where possible, remove the original removable liner before fitting a full-length orthotic.

Stacking two full-length inserts may:

  • Reduce toe room
  • Push the heel upwards
  • Create pressure across the top of the foot
  • Cause heel slippage
  • Change the location of the arch support
  • Make the footwear unstable

The orthotic should sit flat against the base of the shoe unless its instructions state otherwise.

How Should An Orthotic Fit?

Check that:

  • The heel rests fully within the rear section
  • The arch contour sits beneath the natural arch
  • The device remains flat
  • The edges do not curl
  • The toes remain unrestricted
  • The heel does not slip
  • The shoe still fastens securely
  • The orthotic cannot move forwards or sideways
  • There is no sharp or concentrated pressure

A support that is too short or long may position the arch contour incorrectly.

Correct sizing matters even where the toe section can be trimmed.

How Long Does It Take To Adapt?

Structured orthotics may feel unfamiliar initially because they alter support and pressure beneath the feet.

Introduce them gradually:

  1. Begin with up to one hour during ordinary activity.
  2. Check for rubbing, redness or pressure.
  3. Increase wearing time by approximately 30 to 60 minutes each day.
  4. Become comfortable walking before using them for a full work shift.
  5. Avoid first testing them during a long run or unusually active day.
  6. Stop if severe pain, numbness or skin damage develops.

Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS guidance recommends gradually increasing wear over approximately one to two weeks. RNOH advises aiming towards all-day use within two to three weeks where the devices remain comfortable.

How Should The Orthotics Feel?

A suitable device may feel noticeable beneath the arch but should not feel sharply painful.

Positive signs may include:

  • Improved stability
  • Reduced foot fatigue
  • Better walking tolerance
  • Less arch or heel discomfort
  • Greater comfort during prolonged standing
  • Fewer symptom flare-ups
  • No skin irritation

Warning signs include:

  • Sharp arch pressure
  • Numbness or tingling
  • Persistent rubbing
  • Toe compression
  • Heel slippage
  • Increasing instability
  • New pain elsewhere
  • Skin damage

NHS guidance advises removing insoles and seeking review where discomfort continues or severe pain develops.

Can Orthotics Make Symptoms Worse?

Potentially, if the device is unsuitable or fitted incorrectly.

Problems may occur when an orthotic is:

  • Too high beneath the arch
  • Too firm
  • Too soft
  • The wrong size
  • Poorly positioned
  • Too thick for the footwear
  • Moving inside the shoe
  • Combined with unsuitable shoes

Possible symptoms include:

  • Increased arch pain
  • Heel discomfort
  • Forefoot pressure
  • Rubbing
  • Numbness
  • Instability
  • New leg or back discomfort

Insoles can alter standing and walking and may occasionally cause symptoms elsewhere in the lower body. Severe or continuing pain is a reason to stop using them and reassess the device.

Do Orthotics Replace Exercise?

No.

Orthotics provide support while being worn, but they do not build strength, balance or endurance.

Depending on the person’s symptoms, a wider programme may include:

  • Calf raises
  • Foot-muscle exercises
  • Balance work
  • Ankle-strengthening exercises
  • Calf flexibility exercises
  • Gradual walking progression
  • Appropriate activity modification
  • Supportive footwear

Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS guidance notes that insoles are commonly supplied as one part of a wider care plan that may include rehabilitation, strapping and footwear changes.

Do Orthotics Permanently Correct Overpronation?

Generally, no.

Orthotics may alter support, pressure and movement while they are inside the footwear.

They do not usually:

  • Permanently create an arch
  • Permanently realign the foot
  • Alter the length of bones
  • Remove all natural pronation
  • Replace muscle strength
  • Cure every cause of foot pain

The NHS states that insoles may ease symptoms associated with flat feet but do not change the shape of the feet.

The objective is improved comfort and function rather than permanently forcing the foot into a particular appearance.

Why Choose The Bio Advanced Full Length Insole?

The Bio Advanced Full Length Insole is a flexible EVA orthotic designed to provide structured support through the heel, arch and forefoot.

Its features include:

  • Flexible EVA construction
  • Multiple support densities
  • Full-length coverage
  • Intrinsic 4° rearfoot support
  • A metatarsal raise
  • Sustentaculum tali support
  • An antimicrobial microfibre top cover
  • Heat-mouldable and grindable construction
  • Self-adhesive customisation components
  • Multiple sizes
  • Supplied as a pair

The included components provide options for heel cushioning, forefoot and rearfoot wedging, heel elevation and selected pressure-relief modifications. The current product information states that it may contain latex.

Orthotix lists the Bio Advanced for uses including overpronation, low arches, plantar fasciitis, pressure relief and sore or tired feet.

Who May Benefit From Bio Advanced?

The Bio Advanced may be worth considering where the wearer requires:

  • More support than a flat cushioning insole
  • A contoured medial arch
  • Rearfoot stability
  • Full-length pressure distribution
  • A flexible EVA construction
  • A choice of support density
  • Scope for professional adjustment
  • An orthotic for supportive everyday or sports footwear

It may be less suitable where:

  • The footwear is too shallow
  • Strong arch contact is poorly tolerated
  • Only light cushioning is required
  • The feet require substantially different custom prescriptions
  • A complex deformity needs individual accommodation
  • There is a known latex sensitivity
  • A healthcare professional recommends another design

When Might Cushioning Alone Be Better?

A cushioning insole may be more suitable where the main priorities are:

  • Shock absorption
  • Heel cushioning
  • Forefoot comfort
  • Pressure relief
  • Standing on hard floors
  • Reduced general foot fatigue
  • Minimal arch contouring

The Airyplant® PRO is the cushioning option featured elsewhere within this advice hub.

The correct choice depends on whether the wearer needs soft pressure relief or more structured arch and rearfoot support.

When Should You Seek Professional Assessment?

Professional assessment may be beneficial where:

  • Pain is severe or persistent
  • The arch has recently changed
  • Only one foot is affected
  • Walking or balance is impaired
  • Numbness or weakness is present
  • Ankle injuries repeatedly occur
  • Standard orthotics remain uncomfortable
  • Skin damage develops
  • Previous surgery or injury has changed the foot
  • A custom prescription may be required

A podiatrist or orthotist can assess symptoms, foot shape, movement, pressure, footwear and activity before recommending cushioning, prefabricated support, professional modification or a custom device.

The Key Takeaway

Orthotic insoles may help symptomatic overpronation by:

  • Supporting the arch
  • Improving rearfoot stability
  • Redistributing pressure
  • Reducing excessive or poorly controlled inward movement
  • Improving comfort during walking and standing
  • Reducing fatigue associated with unsupported feet

However, pronation is a normal part of movement, and painless flat or pronated feet do not automatically require correction.

The most suitable orthotic should provide comfortable support without creating excessive pressure. It should be worn inside appropriate footwear and used alongside strengthening, rehabilitation or activity management where required.

Bio Advanced Full Length Insole

Bio Advanced Full Length Insole

The Bio Advanced Full Length Insole offers clinically engineered, flexible EVA support tailored to individual biomechanical needs. It comes in multiple densities—low, medium, and high—and in both full and ¾ lengths, making it suitable for a broad range of patients. Moreover, the...
£79.95
View Recommended Support

Related Advice

Do Arch Support Insoles Help Plantar Fasciitis?

Do Arch Support Insoles Help Plantar Fasciitis?

Read advice
What Are Orthotic Insoles Used For?

What Are Orthotic Insoles Used For?

Read advice
Off-The-Shelf vs Custom Orthotics

Off-The-Shelf vs Custom Orthotics

Read advice

When Should You Seek Professional Advice?

Seek advice from a podiatrist, physiotherapist, orthotist or GP if inward foot movement is accompanied by persistent pain, weakness, numbness, repeated ankle injuries, difficulty walking or problems with balance.

Professional assessment is particularly important if the arch has recently become flatter, the change affects only one foot or the foot has become increasingly stiff or swollen.

Stop using the orthotics and reassess their fit if they cause sharp arch pressure, rubbing, numbness, instability or new pain in the feet, ankles, knees, hips or back. People with diabetes, poor circulation, reduced sensation, fragile skin or an existing wound should obtain professional guidance before independently using a strongly contoured orthotic.
Back to top